When deciding between repairing or replacing your commercial roof, you face a challenging choice. Your roof serves as a vital investment safeguarding your business and its assets. Making an informed decision is paramount when it comes to your building’s needs. The age, condition, repair history of the roof, and overall cost-effectiveness are all factors to consider.

Here is a deeper look into the key considerations to help determine whether your commercial roof need repair or replacement.

Assessing the Roof’s Condition

To make a decision about your commercial roof, start by assessing its current condition. Discuss what a thorough inspection entails with a reputable local roofing contractor. They should evaluate any damage present, identify underlying issues, and provide you with an expert assessment and plan of action.

Age of the Roof

Considering the age of your roof is essential. Depending on the materials used and your maintenance schedule through the years, most commercial roofs have a lifespan of at least 20 to 30 years. If your roof is nearing its expected lifespan and requires frequent repairs, it might be more cost-effective to replace it instead of continually addressing individual issues.

Extent of Damage and Repairs Needed

Assessing the extent of damage and determining necessary repairs is crucial. Sometimes roof damage is limited to a specific area of the roof. If that’s the case, then a repair may suffice. However, in cases where the damage spans across multiple areas or occurs repeatedly, considering a replacement can offer a more sustainable solution, preventing recurring expenses for repairs.

Cost Considerations

Considering the cost implications of repair versus replacement is essential. While opting for repairs might appear more cost-effective in the short term, it’s important to recognize that frequent repairs can accumulate expenses over time, especially for aging roofs. Moreover, older roofs may harbor concealed issues that can resurface unexpectedly, leading to additional costs. In contrast, choosing a roof replacement offers an opportunity for a fresh start with enhanced materials and better durability.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

A thorough evaluation of your roof’s energy efficiency and sustainability aspects is recommended. Modern roofing materials offer enhanced insulation capabilities, leading to reduced energy consumption and more manageable utility bills. Additionally, exploring environmentally friendly options such as cool roofs or solar panels can actively contribute to sustainability efforts. Notably, these choices may even qualify your business for advantageous tax credits or incentives. Consider a Duro-Last Roofing system, it meets all the criteria of a sound, durable and energy efficient roof for your building. It will last decades, save you money and its better for the environment than other roofing materials.

Future Plans and Business Goals

Considering your future plans and business goals, it is crucial to evaluate whether expanding or remodeling your building necessitates a replacement roof. Opting for a new roofing system offers greater flexibility and ensures seamless integration with the updated structure. Conversely, if selling the property or relocating aligns with your long-term plans, maintaining the current roof may suffice without immediate replacement.

Consulting with Professionals

To make the right decision, it’s essential to seek expert advice from professional commercial roofing contractors. These experts possess extensive experience in assessing roofs and providing customized solutions. By consulting with them, they will guide you through the decision-making process while considering your specific needs and objectives. With their assistance, you can confidently make an informed choice that aligns with your budget and goals.


Deciding whether to repair or replace your commercial roof is a significant task. It involves assessing the condition, age, extent of damage, and cost considerations of the roof. These steps are crucial in making an informed decision for your business. By evaluating these factors and consulting with professional roofing contractors, you can determine the right choice – either repair or replacement – that fits your needs. Remember, maintaining a dependable roof is essential for safeguarding your assets and ensuring the long-term success of your commercial enterprise.

Call MacDermott Roofing located in the Metro area for a no-obligation quote on commercial roofing services. We are an experienced and highly skilled industrial roofing contractor with a commitment to customer care and satisfaction. We specialize in commercial roof repair, installation, roof maintenance as well as provide support for mechanical contractors.