Skip to main content
A Proud Duro-Last® Platinum Contractor Serving Southeast Michigan

What Are the Signs Your Commercial Roof Needs Replacing?

As a business owner, you may be wondering when it is more economical to replace your commercial roof or repair it. Replacing a roof can be a hefty initial expense that pays off by helping you avoid more serious, expensive damages and repairs in the future.

So, what are the signs that your commercial roof needs replacing?

Generally, any severe damage to your roof means that you will need a replacement. Poor insulation, water damage, damage to the roof membrane, and any visible damage to the roof itself are all reasons to consider a replacement roof.

If you have more questions about the specifics of replacing your commercial roof, keep reading to learn how to decide whether to repair or replace your roof.

Poor Insulation and High Energy Costs

If you notice that your energy costs are increasing without making any changes, then your roof is likely to blame. Old roofs that lack effective insulation can significantly increase your energy costs by allowing too much airflow.

Water Damage

Water damage is one of the most common reasons that business owners choose to replace their commercial roofs. If you notice that water is leaking into your building, then you should identify the source of the water and consider replacing the roof depending on the extent of water damage.

Commercial roofs are especially susceptible to water damage because they are generally flat and allow water to pool on top. If you live in an area with frequent rain and high amounts of precipitation, you need to be vigilant and make sure that your commercial roof is continuing to keep water out.

Water spots around your building are a definite sign that you need to replace your commercial roof. Water spots around your building may indicate that your roof is beginning to decay, leading to more severe problems in the future.

Damage to Roof Membrane

Damage to your roof membrane is another reason to replace your roof instead of repairing it. Damage to the roof membrane occurs when extreme wind or storm conditions cause uplifting. If uplifting is left unchecked, it can contribute to additional water damage in your building.

If you can see uplifting on your roof membrane, then it is already too late for repairs. You should contact a specialist to assess your roof as soon as you notice signs of uplifting.

Visible Damage to Roof Exterior

A final reason to replace your commercial roof instead of repairing it is any visible damage to the exterior of your roof. Visible damage to your roof can only lead to more expensive damage in the future, so getting ahead of the curve and replacing your roof before damages get too out-of-hand can save you thousands in the future.

Signs That a Metal Roof Needs Replacing

Many business owners favor metal for their commercial roofs because it is durable and long-lasting. While metal roofs can be patched to prevent minor damage, you should consider replacing your roof if you notice any of the following signs:

• Displaced metal sheets
• Missing fasteners
• Rust
• Torn or warped metal sheets

Signs That a Shingled Roof Needs Replacing

Shingled roofs are also common among business owners because they are highly cost-efficient. Shingled roofs are more susceptible to external threats and extreme water damage, so you are more likely to need to replace your shingled roof.

If you notice any of the following signs, you should contact a roofing expert to replace your commercial roof as soon as possible.

• Missing or broken shingles
• Moss growth and other signs of water damage
• Cracked or visibly damaged shingles

Conclusion

While it may be a large investment to replace your commercial roof, consider the thousands that you can save by avoiding severe damage to your building. As a business owner, you should always be vigilant and make sure that your roof is in the best condition — always contact a roofing professional as soon as you notice signs that you may need to replace your roof.

As experts in the commercial roofing industry, MacDermott Roofing has a reputation or service, technical skill, and product knowledge. We have been providing commercial roofing installation, replacement, and repair throughout the Detroit metropolitan area for over 40 years. Call us today for a Free Estimate on your commercial roof project!

More Posts

Commercial Roofing Across Metro Detroit & Southeast Michigan
Primary Service Area: Livonia • Detroit • Ann Arbor • Wayne County • Oakland County • Washtenaw County • Macomb County • Livingston County
Fully licensed and insured roofing professionals. © 2026 MacDermott Roofing | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

Austin Akers

Austin oversees commercial roofing projects across Southeast Michigan for MacDermott Roofing. He is passionate about building strong client relationships, leading successful projects, and delivering high-quality roofing solutions. His commitment to hard work, communication, and customer service helps ensure every project is completed to the highest standard.

Julia Hicks

Julia has 15+ years experience in various professional capacities and industries focused on process improvement, people management, customer service and project management. She began her career at MacDermott as a Service Coordinator and Human Resource Manager. She is now our Operations Manager focusing on overseeing all aspects of our installation and service departments.

David Chene

David has been with MacDermott Roofing for more than 25 years. He is our chief estimator, dedicated to serving our customer’s needs and managing existing accounts for the benefit of our customers. He has experience with new construction and existing projects, private customer, and general contractors.

David M. Wilson

David has 35 Years of experience in the Metro Detroit construction industry, including 20 years with a mid-sized general contractor as Executive Vice President. 7 yrs as the owner of a land development company specializing in Urban infill mid-rise developments. 10 yrs as an independent construction consultant focused on Strategic Planning, Project Management, Dispute resolution, and Claims management.